Boyd W Arthurs Middle School vs. Shumate Middle School
Should you attend Boyd W Arthurs Middle School or Shumate Middle School? Visitors to our site frequently compare these two schools. Compare their rankings, test scores, reviews and more to help you determine which school is the best choice for you.
School Overview
School
Overview
Serving 513 students in grades 6-8, Boyd W Arthurs Middle School ranks in the top 50% of all schools in Michigan for overall test scores (math proficiency is top 50%, and reading proficiency is top 50%).
The percentage of students achieving proficiency in math is 41% (which is higher than the Michigan state average of 34%). The percentage of students achieving proficiency in reading/language arts is 52% (which is higher than the Michigan state average of 45%).
The student:teacher ratio of 15:1 is lower than the Michigan state level of 17:1.
Minority enrollment is 15% of the student body (majority Hispanic), which is lower than the Michigan state average of 36% (majority Black).
Serving 795 students in grades 6-8, Shumate Middle School ranks in the bottom 50% of all schools in Michigan for overall test scores (math proficiency is top 50%, and reading proficiency is top 50%).
The percentage of students achieving proficiency in math is 32% (which is lower than the Michigan state average of 34%). The percentage of students achieving proficiency in reading/language arts is 44% (which is lower than the Michigan state average of 45%).
The student:teacher ratio of 21:1 is higher than the Michigan state level of 17:1.
Minority enrollment is 22% of the student body (majority Hispanic and Black), which is lower than the Michigan state average of 36% (majority Black).
Grades Offered
6-8
6-8
Total Students
513 students
795 students
![This chart displays total students of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays total students of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/total_students/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-bl8I3c2.png)
![This chart displays total students of Shumate Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays total students of Shumate Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/total_students/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-7WW9Kj.png)
% Male | % Female
49% | 51%
54% | 46%
![This chart displays gender of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School This chart displays gender of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/gender/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-bjI8t0B.png)
![This chart displays gender of Shumate Middle School This chart displays gender of Shumate Middle School](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/gender/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-b43IYfb.png)
Total Classroom Teachers
35 teachers
38 teachers
![This chart displays the total teachers of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the total teachers of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/total_teachers/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-W3ziPD.png)
![This chart displays the total teachers of Shumate Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the total teachers of Shumate Middle School by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/total_teachers/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-SH5wQQ.png)
Student : Teacher Ratio
15:1
21:1
![This chart displays the student teacher ratio of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the public school average student teacher ratio of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the student teacher ratio of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the public school average student teacher ratio of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/teacher_student_ratio/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-0zN2gg.png)
![This chart displays the student teacher ratio of Shumate Middle School and the public school average student teacher ratio of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the student teacher ratio of Shumate Middle School and the public school average student teacher ratio of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/teacher_student_ratio/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-7XJMjJ.png)
Test Scores
Overall Testing Rank
#1073 out of 3069 schools in MI
(Top 50%)
(Top 50%)
#1543 out of 3069 schools in MI
(Bottom 50%)
(Bottom 50%)
![This chart displays the overall school rank of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the overall school rank of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/overall_school_rank/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-ZTqhhh.png)
![This chart displays the overall school rank of Shumate Middle School, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the overall school rank of Shumate Middle School, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/overall_school_rank/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-5SLHJq.png)
Math Test Scores (% Proficient)
41%
32%
![This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/math_percent/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-DxZaAR.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Math of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/math_percent/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-2iqXdD.png)
Reading/Language Arts Test Scores (% Proficient)
52%
44%
![This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/rla_percent/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-bhyIa6X.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Reading/Language Arts of Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/rla_percent/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-bljrJa5.png)
Science Test Scores (% Proficient)
35-39%
35%
![This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/sci_percent/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-bf8e1dF.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students that scored at or above 'proficient' levels in Science of public schools in Michigan by year, with the latest 2021-22 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/sci_percent/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-KUnoaV.png)
Students by Grade
Students by Grade
![This chart displays the students of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School by grade. This chart displays the students of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School by grade.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/students_by_grade/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-W5LZ7V.png)
![This chart displays the students of Shumate Middle School by grade. This chart displays the students of Shumate Middle School by grade.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/students_by_grade/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-y7uhN1.png)
Grade 6 Students
186
295
Grade 7 Students
183
261
Grade 8 Students
144
239
Students by Ethnicity
% American Indian
n/a
n/a
![This chart displays the percentage of American Indian students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and percentage of American Indian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 1997-98 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of American Indian students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and percentage of American Indian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 1997-98 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/american_indian_ethnicity/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-SHEir9.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of American Indian students in Shumate Middle School and percentage of American Indian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2012-13 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of American Indian students in Shumate Middle School and percentage of American Indian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2012-13 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/american_indian_ethnicity/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-h7OzEC.png)
% Asian
1%
2%
![This chart displays the percentage of Asian students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of Asian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of Asian students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of Asian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/asian_islander_ethnicity/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-fERZY0.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of Asian students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of Asian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of Asian students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of Asian public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/asian_islander_ethnicity/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-NcPWBp.png)
% Hispanic
9%
9%
![This chart displays the percentage of Hispanic students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of Hispanic public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of Hispanic students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of Hispanic public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/hispanic_students_ethnicity/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-SHU6F9.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of Hispanic students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of Hispanic public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of Hispanic students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of Hispanic public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/hispanic_students_ethnicity/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-fESP6f.png)
% Black
2%
7%
![This chart displays the percentage of Black students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of Black public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of Black students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of Black public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/black_students_ethnicity/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-4l4IKm.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of Black students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of Black public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of Black students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of Black public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/black_students_ethnicity/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-F5qvHj.png)
% White
85%
78%
![This chart displays the percentage of White students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of White public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of White students in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of White public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/white_students_ethnicity/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-byMI6qx.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of White students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of White public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of White students in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of White public school students in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/white_students_ethnicity/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-h7T82C.png)
% Hawaiian
n/a
n/a
% Two or more races
3%
4%
![This chart displays the percentage of students of two or more races in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students of two or more races in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students of two or more races in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students of two or more races in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/two_or_more_races_students_ethnicity/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-bfVqCs6.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of students of two or more races in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students of two or more races in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students of two or more races in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students of two or more races in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/two_or_more_races_students_ethnicity/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-baquqog.png)
Diversity Score
0.27
0.38
![This chart displays the diversity score of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the public school average diversity score of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the diversity score of Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the public school average diversity score of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/diversity_score/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-ltWMyf.png)
![This chart displays the diversity score of Shumate Middle School and the public school average diversity score of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the diversity score of Shumate Middle School and the public school average diversity score of Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/diversity_score/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-BJPk8j.png)
Additional Information
Eligible for Free Lunch
29%
31%
![This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for free lunch in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for free lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for free lunch in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for free lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/freelunch_students/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-YxWZkV.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for free lunch in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for free lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for free lunch in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for free lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/freelunch_students/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-btiVKbc.png)
Eligible for Reduced Lunch
3%
4%
![This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Boyd W Arthurs Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/reduced_pricelunch_students/42000/42317/boyd-w-arthurs-middle-school-chart-bn4k7OF.png)
![This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data. This chart displays the percentage of students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Shumate Middle School and the percentage of public school students who is eligible for reduced lunch in Michigan by year, with the latest 2022-23 school year data.](http://images2.publicschoolreview.com/charts/reduced_pricelunch_students/41000/40515/shumate-middle-school-chart-j1bspj.png)